Monaco princess Charlotte Casiraghi branded 'ignorant' over Native American costume at Paris showjumping event
|
The Monaco royal, 26, who chose the ensemble to participate in the Gucci-sponsored Paris Masters International Jumping Competition this weekend, was branded 'ignorant' and 'racist' by Tumblr users, many of whom appeared to be royal fans, judging by their usernames.
Royalwatcher wrote on the site: 'I don’t know who told her it was cute to dress in traditonal [sic] clothing of Native American but gurlll, I’m judging you and not in the good way.'
Controversy: Charlotte Casiraghi sparked anger from royal watchers when she competed in a Native American costume at the Gucci Paris Masters on Saturday
Another, named Prin-ses-ka-ro-leen, added: 'Dear Charlotte Casiraghi, American Indians still endure racism, ignorance and abuse on a regular basis simply because they are Native. You displayed terribly poor judgment in your choice of "outfit."'
And Icaughtafallingdream wrote: 'It’s not cute and it’s not funny. It’s just insulting and dumb.'
Given that the controversy follows a series of similar missteps from Victoria's Secret, Urban Outfitters and Gwen Stefani, the fashion website Styleite questioned whether there was some poor judgement on the part of Gucci, the sponsor of the tournament and the brand Miss Casiraghi represents.
Inappropriate? The Monegasque royal ignited debate on Tumblr, where users deemed the costume 'ignorant'
'Other riders dressed up as Roman warriors, donkeys, angels, and Flintstones - you know, costumes - while Casiraghi opted for an outfit that has been publicly denounced as racist time and time again,' reporter Hilary George-Parkin wrote.
'As the royal is the face of an international luxury brand (however reluctantly), one would think there would be more oversight [sic] on Gucci’s part.'
The costume certainly adds fuel to an already heated debate about representation of Native Americans in popular culture.
Cool or clumsy? The costume certainly adds fuel to an already heated debate about representation of Native Americans in popular culture
Supporters: The commentary on Miss Casiraghi's costume was not all negative, however. Several Tumblr users spoke out in her defence
FROM URBAN OUTFITTERS TO VICTORIA'S SECRET: FASHION AND THE NATIVE AMERICAN TREND
NOVEMBER 12 2012: Victoria's Secret is forced to apologise after supermodel Karlie Kloss walks its catwalk show in a feather headdress, suede lingerie and turquoise jewellery. In a message to its 1.4million Twitter followers, it promised to remove the outfit from the upcoming broadcast on December 4.
NOVEMBER 5 2012: The video for No Doubt track Looking Hot is removed from YouTube, after complaints from fans and the Native American community. The band, fronted by Gwen Stefani, apologised on their website to anyone who may have been offended, stating: 'Being hurtful to anyone is simply not who we are.'
13 OCTOBER 2011: Urban Outfitters is accused of breaking the law over its use of the word 'Navajo' to describe items on sale. Urban Outfitters told MailOnline: 'The Native American-inspired trend and specifically the term "Navajo" have been cycling thru fashion, fine art and design for the last few years.'
Sasha Houston Brown, a member of the Santee Sioux tribe of Nebraska and a vocal champion of Native American culture, wrote last month on the Racialicious blog: 'Despite what dominant society and mainstream media say, Native culture is a vibrant and living culture.
'We are not a relic of the past, a theme or a trend; we are not a style or costume; we are not mascots, noble savages or romantic fictional entities. We are human beings and, despite all odds, we have survived.
'As sovereign Nations, Indigenous peoples have the right to speak for ourselves and not have dominant Euro-American society project and profit off of an artificial and socially constructed image of “Indian” identity.'
The commentary on Miss Casiraghi's costume was not all negative, however. Several Tumblr users spoke out in her defence.
Josephg wrote on the thread: 'i think she look gorgeous :)'
Intomyfoyer went further, pointing out that it was Gucci's choice of costume, and blame should not be cast on Miss Casiraghi.
'It doesn’t mean she has no idea about America’s past, she’s not dumb...' they wrote.
'This whole thing will be offensive only if YOU make it offensive, no one had the intentions of offending anyone in any way.'
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2242511/Monaco-princess-Charlotte-Casiraghi-branded-ignorant-Native-American-costume-Paris-showjumping-event.html#ixzz2E2K4MTzA
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook